Showing posts with label Lincoln Assassination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lincoln Assassination. Show all posts

Sunday, December 6, 2020

First Impressions: The Conspiracy Between John Wilkes Booth and the Union Army to Assassinate Abraham Lincoln

After reading several books this year concerning the War of Northern Aggression and the Lincoln assassination, I can finally say that the case and mysteries surrounding the final disposition of John Booth have been settled.

We published a recent Chronicle in which we sat on a fence concerning the capture and death of John Booth, conceding that it was not an open and shut case whether or not he got away with murder. With the help of Dr. Robert Arnold, I am no longer reticent about Booth's demise. The famous (or infamous) actor escaped one of the most intense manhunts in history, and lived to tell about it, a habit which led ultimately to his demise in 1903.

Like some of the other authors I have read, Arnold, a retired US Naval surgeon, lays out the case for a conspiracy to murder Lincoln, one which centered on the Union Army and Edwin Stanton. While the other books elaborate the conspiracy more fully, and include more people, such as Andrew Johnson, Arnold focuses on the lower level of the action - ie rehearsing the details at the crime scene, the manhunt for Booth, the medical situation of Booth, the trial, and others at Stanton's level and below.

Most importantly, Arnold exhumed records from the National Archives which shed new light - even after 150 years - on the crime of the 19th century. For example, we find out that there was an army caravan of around 10 wagons each hitched to teams of 4 horses lining the road leading from the Navy Yard Bridge, a fact which was never disclosed to the public, but whose presence most assuredly ensured Booth's safety in the same way that Silas Cobb's disobedience to orders prohibiting exits after 9p enabled Booth to escape.

We also find out that it was most improbable that David Harold accompanied Lewis Powell to Seward's residence in an attempted murder. Harold had more than likely left Washington, DC before the gates closed anticipating to rendezvous with Booth after he completed his job at Ford's Theatre. 

The old fable that Major Rowan O'Beirne sent the telegram to Stanton which reported Booth and Harold crossing the Potomac is laid to rest. The telegram miraculously survived the decades and clearly has no information about the fugitives crossing the river into Virginia - or anywhere else for that matter. This was a ruse to provide a plausible explanation about how Booth and company were finally found - the point being that Stanton knew full well that a fake Booth would die at Garrett's farm.

Captain Willie Jett, a Confederate veteran, very briefly with Mosby's Rangers, was not captured at the Star Hotel but at the Gouldman residence, the home of his future wife. Jett was placed under a staged arrest to give him cover as he assisted Lt Colonel Everton Conger and Lt Luther Baker in their capture of "Booth."

But this brings us to one of the most important facets of the book - namely that John Wilkes Booth was not the man captured at Garrett's farm. Arnold explains that the two Garret sons, William and John, were Confederate soldiers who were given leave from service in order to assist in the staging of the capture and killing of Booth.

As it turns out, Booth was swapped with a man named James Boyd who was a hapless victim of being in the wrong place at the wrong time. He suffered a war injury which required use of cane, which plausibly mimicked Booth's fracture ankle, but he was the scape goat in the charade which allowed Booth to escape.

He was allowed to stay for a couple of days in Garret's home, but Richard, the father of John and William, decided that he was no longer welcome. However, he and Boyd were allowed one last night in the barn which the two sons locked for safe keeping. The argument advanced by one author was that they were locked in so that they would not steal any horses or other property. However, the real reason was that they were being kept for the slaughter to occur within a few hours upon Lt Doherty's arrival with his 25 man mounted squadron from the New York 16th Infantry. The horses had been removed from the barn in anticipation of its burning in the early morning hours.

John and William kept guard in the corn crib to make sure that the two men did not escape, and to make contact with Conger and Baker as they planned the final actions resulting in the death of Boyd.

The scheme was to find someone with enough resemblance to Booth who, when burned, could plausibly be passed off as Booth. The plan failed due to Doherty's interferences, so Conger scrambled at the last minute to kill Boyd after Harold surrendered. Boston Corbett was not the man who shot Boyd as Arnold shows from the ballistics of the wound. Under no circumstances could Boyd be taken alive.

Boyd died within minutes of shooting, his body packed up to be carried along with Jett and Baker, Conger having left for Washington to deliver the property of Booth to Stanton. The personal articles partly provided the plausible identification of the victim. Since Boyd was wearing a Confederate uniform, he was taken by Baker and Doherty to be dressed in black clothing in order to simulate what Booth wore to the assassination. This explains the long absence between Doherty's unit and Baker and Jett.

The autopsy on the Montauk was another farce, the central feature being that the only possibly credible witness was Dr John May who initially claimed that the body could not be that Booth, but finally relented under pressure to make the identification on the flimsy evidence of the scar on Booth's and Boyd's necks. Contrary to our previous belief, there is no evidence that Booth's dentist identified the corpse, nor is he listed in the index of witnesses in the National Archive records.

The corpse was brought aboard the Montauk in the middle of the night, and just as mysteriously taken away the following day to be buried in the old penitentiary in Washington in a cell to which only Stanton held the key.

Arnold reduces a mass of information and contradictions into an easily understandable conspiracy involving both the Union army and elements of the Confederacy who collaborated as strange bedfellows to murder Lincoln, each party having its own reasons for doing so.

Ultimately the South got the bad end of the bargain for it suffered under the Radical Republicans' reign of terror, something which Johnson fought unsuccessfully. However, he was able to pardon all Confederate soldiers and politicians, as well as the surviving victims of General Joseph Holt's kangaroo court which murdered innocent victims such as Mary Surrat - all under direction from Stanton.

The Conspiracy contains much more fascinating details surrounding the planning and execution of the assassination, but it makes clear that it was not the work of a lone gunman who suddenly at the last minute decided on one last mad act.

The time has come to rewrite the history books and tell the truth. Unfortunately that will never happen any time soon. The government, even today, has too much to risk in such a confession.

Reference
Dr Robert E Arnold, The Conspiracy Between John Wilkes Booth and the Union Army to Assassinate Abraham Lincoln, Windsaloft Publishing, Lexington, KY, 2016, 396pp, illustrated

Copyright 2020 Tony Bonn. All rights reserved.

Saturday, September 26, 2020

Did Laura Keene Nurse the Assassinated Lincoln?

One of  the secondary threads of the Lincoln assassination story describes how actress Laura Keene left the stage of Ford's Theatre to nurse the dying Lincoln by holding his head on her lap while doctors administered life saving measures. The story has been derided by some, but enough new evidence has emerged to give it a new lease on life.

The Lincoln literature is a vast hall of mirrors, where ambiguous and secondary evidence has morphed into holy writ - not to be doubted or questioned. The story of Keene's involvement in the assassination aftermath is not quite to that level, but is generally related as a matter of fact.

The background for this story is that Keene, a prominent British actress appearing in a production of Our American Cousin at Ford's Theater in Washington, DC, rushed for the presidential box when she realized what had happened to the president.

When she arrived, she is alleged to have asked the attending physician, Charles Leale, to hold Lincoln's head. As Leale reports in 1909,
While we were waiting for Mr. Lincoln to gain strength Laura Keene, who had been taking part in the play, appealed to me to allow her to hold the President's head. I granted this request and she sat on the floor of the box and held his head on her lap.
If that were not enough, there are supposedly patches taken from her costume retaining blood stains from Lincoln's wound. The National Museum of American History holds one of these relics.

Yet historian Norman Gasbarro expressed skepticism about this story, noting the logistical improbabilities of gaining access to the president's room in the pandemonium reigning at Ford's Theater immediately after the shooting of the president.

Writing on his fine Civil War Blog website, Gasbarro states:
Other eyewitness accounts are given, some stating that Keene was in the state box and some stating that she was not. Harbin does state rather emphatically that no one who made any of these statements ever testified at the trail of the conspirators, and that the statements were actually made many years later – Seaton Munroe (31 years),  Dr. Charles Leale (44 years), Jeannie Gourlay (58 years) and William Ferguson (65 years).  Harbin concludes by stating that it all comes down to deciding “which eyewitnesses… you believe” and that it is doubtful whether any conclusive proof will ever come forward.
Gasbarro rightly objects to the absence of contemporary accounts corroborated by first hand witnesses. Had these witnesses been deposed under oath, this matter would probably be settled. And why weren't they called to the witness stand? First hand witnesses are quite valuable to court cases. But alas, this matter is secondary to a murder case.

But witnesses, especially decades after the fact, can be troublesome, especially when other first hand witnesses contradict them. In this case, Clara Harris, whom Mary Lincoln had invited to accompany her and her husband to the play, claimed adamantly that Laura Keene was never in the president's box. Gasbarro concludes as follows:
Even more deceptive, is that after relying almost completely on Reck as a source, Steers fails to state the two important points in Reck’s conclusion:  (1) that Clara Harris, who was the Lincoln’s guest in the state box that night, vehemently denied that Laura Keene was ever at any time in the state box (Reck, p. 123), and (2) “No statement from Miss Keene about the alleged occurrence has ever been seen (Reck, p. 123).”
Nonetheless, Gasbarro leaves open the possibility that new evidence might confirm or contradict the legend of Laura Keene. Interestingly, such evidence emerged after he wrote his articles in 2012.

In the audience of the Ford Theater that evening was W. Martin Jones who described his location in a letter to Captain Bowen, dated April 24, 1865:
The theatre was well filled, and the play opened soon after eight oclock [sic]. I occupied a front seat in the first section from the private box fitted up for the Presidential company, which was on the right hand side of the audience.
In his mellifluous and hagiographic letter concerning Lincoln, he later describes the moments immediately after the shot of gunfire is heard:
Laura Keene stepped forward and endeavored to restore quiet, but suddenly, was seized with a new thought, she rushed to the President's box, and taking the head of the murdered man in her lap, did what she could to bring back the life that was fast passing away. Thus in the public theater of Washington the life blood of the illustrious Chief Magistrate of the Nation stained the robe of an Actress [sic]. 
So a very contemporary witness, writing 10 days after his visit to Ford's Theater, avers that Laura Keene indeed held the dying president's head in her lap. Reading this passage from a contemporaneous letter of the event, one could say, Case closed, and be done with it.

However, it is not so simple as that. On the one hand, this story is not a late invention. It is part of the earliest days of the assassination's history and legend. Even though others told this story in later years, it appeared much earlier - from the very beginning from someone who was a witness to the events at the theater.

There is one small problem. Jones' letter is a conflation of events he personally witnessed and read. He describes aspects of the funeral, visitation, and mourning of Washington, some of which he did not personally attend. In other words, his account contains a mixture of first and second hand accounts. Thus we ask, Did Jones actually see Keene in the state box of Ford' Theater - let alone hold the president's head?

His extremely valuable contribution was describing Laura Keene's actions in the very moments after the assassin left the stage. However, there is not enough evidence contained in his witness to suggest that Keene succeeded in her attempt to reach Lincoln. Jones notes that the theater was quickly cleared, so it seems doubtful that he had enough time to actually witness Keene enter the presidential box. They would have been moving in opposite directions, so it seems likely that our correspondent would have noted her in passing, yet says nothing of such an encounter.

Our conclusion is that Keene did not attend to the president. She attempted to do so, but failed. However, if firm DNA evidence from the alleged swatches from her dress confirm that the blood is Lincoln's, we would readily concede the point.

The morals of the story are that eye witnesses can produce conflicting testimony, and they are not the last word.

Reference
Norman Gasbarro, Laura Keene and the Bloody Dress, Civil War Blog, January 22, 2012, accessed 9/26/2020, http://civilwar.gratzpa.org/2012/01/laura-keene-and-the-bloody-dress/

W Martin Jones, Letter to Captain Bowen, April 24, 1865, original facsimile published January 22, 2015 by MailOnline.

Charles A. Leale, MD, Lincoln's Last Hours, February 1909, as reproduced by gutenberg.org, The Project Gutenberg EBook of Lincoln's Last Hours

Copyright 2020 Tony Bonn. All rights reserved.

Friday, March 2, 2012

The Origins of Confederate Black Operations


We often associate the emergence of American black operations (black ops) with the CIA and its post war atrocities. However, the tradition is well documented from the Civil War with some interesting cases from the Confederate States of America involving biological warfare which brought war into its modern phase.

Edward Steers, though not a professional academic historian, has produced some of the best material on the assassination of Abraham Lincoln starting with his scholarly Blood on the Moon which we recommend for, if for no other reason, its debunking of the many ridiculous Lincoln legends associated with his assassination on April 14, 1865. If you still harbor any suspicions that Booth escaped or that Mary Surrat or Samuel Mudd was innocent, then please read Steers’ book.

When we say that the Civil War propelled war into its modern phase, we mean to say that the chivalrous ideals, even if acknowledged only in word, evaporated into smoke in the prosecution of this war. Steers documents how emancipation triggered a sequence of actions leading to covert terrorist activities against civilian populations.

The Confederates maintained two prison camps outside of Richmond whose conditions were deplorably inhumane, due in part to the South’s declining ability to feed itself. When Lincoln discovered from his generals that Richmond was lightly defended, he ordered them to undertake a raid against the camp at Belle Isle, south of the city, to liberate the suffering prisoners.

Colonel Dahlgren, operating under orders from Major General Benjamin Butler and his subordinate Brigadier General Isaac Wistar, led 500 men around the Confederate troops to execute a surprise raid against the prison. Unfortunately Dahlgren’s raid failed in an ambush costing the colonel his life. The Confederates discovered orders on him, in Dahlgren’s hand, whose mission included the killing of CSA president Jefferson Davis and his cabinet.

The CSA made much political hay of this including incensed outrage that anyone would include civilian leadership in such a despicable deed. The North under General Meade strongly denounced the orders in a bid to exculpate his command and president. Steers argues that Meade and Lincoln were certainly aware of the raid and more likely than not to have known about the assassination attempts on southern leadership.

This episode of warfare may have possibly signaled the next major act of aggression by the South which, under the operational direction of Luke Pryor Blackburn, planned a Yellow Fever infection of the populations of Norfolk, VA, New Bern, NC, and President Lincoln.

During the mid 19th century, medical science believed that Yellow Fever was highly contagious, with Blackburn regarded as one of its foremost authorities who was hailed for saving certain southern communities from Yellow Fever epidemics. Fortunately for the targeted victims, this “medical fact” turned out to be false, in much the same way as the farce about HIV causing AIDS.

When one epidemic broke out in Bermuda, Blackburn was dispatched there to assist in the quarantine efforts but also to gather infected garments to be sold in the above named localities in order to precipitate Yellow Fever outbreaks. Union troops were stationed in these areas, thus they were deemed suitable targets.

The trunks of clothing were sequestered until the time to unleash the menace was ordered from either Secretary of War Seddon or Secretary of State Judah. The plot was brought to light during the trial of Lincoln’s murderers and by a Canadian court case in which that nation’s neutrality had been violated by the operations of the CSA's secret service on Canadian soil. The trunks had been shipped through Nova Scotia but was outside Canadian jurisdiction at the time, resulting in a dismissed case.

The key man in both trials was Godfrey J Hyams who was the runner for the trunks who first appeared in the Lincoln trial. His testimony, according to Steers, has been dismissed as unreliable in connection with other Union witnesses who were discovered to be known perjurers during testimony. However, the Toronto case and subsequent correspondence from an Episcopal minister turned spy, Kensey John Stewart, corroborates his story. On December 12, 1864 Stewart notified Jefferson Davis in writing of the plot involving Blackburn. Furthermore, payments owed Hyams and others operating in Canada were specified in gold, a transaction requiring Davis’ explicit authorization.

Thus we see that the Southerners had envisaged, even if on bad medical advice, acts of mass terrorism involving the murder of civilians in an effort to win the war. However, the burning of Georgia and other parts of the South was not a gentleman’s war act either, so we do not claim that either side held the moral high ground.

But the more interesting revelation is that the Civil War was by no means confined to the battle field, a perception which prevails in certain quarters due to the well documented and published narratives of the campaigns and battles fought in the bloodiest American war. We find it interesting that in many ways the war brought the art into the modern age where rifled and automatic weapons gained prominence as did covert operations with spooks operating on Canadian soil for sanctuary. War would never be the same but always hell.

Reference
Blood on the Moon, Edward Steers

Copyright 2010-12 Tony Bonn. All rights reserved.